Last December, after an outing by the Florida sea, I put out an alert about monster lobsters. This reminded me of an illustration by statistical gurus Box and Draper* of a manufacturing improvement method called evolutionary operation (EVOP), which calls for an ongoing series of two-level factorial designs that illuminate a path to more desirable conditions.
With the aid of Design-Expert® software, I reproduced in color the contour plot in Figure 1.3 from the book on EVOP by Box and Draper (see figure at the right). To illustrate the basic principle of evolution, Box and Draper supposed that a series of mutations induced variation in length of lobster claws as well as the pressure the creatures could apply. The contours display the percentage of lobsters at any given combination of length and pressure who survive long enough to reproduce. Naturally this species then evolves toward the optimum of these two attributes as I’ve shown in the middle graph (black and white contours with lobsters crawling all over them).
In this way, Box and Draper present the two key components of natural selection:
- Variation
- An environment that favors select variants.
The strategy of EVOP mimics this process for improvement, but in a controlled fashion. As illustrated here in the left-most plot, a two-level factorial,** with ranges restricted so as not to upset manufacturing, is run repeatedly – often enough to detect a significant improvement. In this case, three cycles suffices to power up the signal-to-noise ratio. This case illustrates a big manufacturing-yield improvement over the course of an EVOP. However, any number of system attributes can be accounted for via multiple-response optimization tools provided by Design-Expert or the like. This ensures that an EVOP will produce more desirable operating conditions overall for process efficiency and product quality.
It pays to pay attention to nature!
*Box, G. E. P. and N. R. Draper, Evolutionary Operation, Wiley New York, 1969. (Wiley Classics Library, paperback edition, 1998.)
**(We show designs with center points as a check for curvature.)